CV Hanna McFadyen Get in touch
Two phones showing the redesigned Rightmove concept: a listing with an Add to compare button, and two properties compared side by side.

Rightmove: Closing the Trust Gap in Property Search

Overview

Independent concept · UX researcher and designer, solo · Usability testing, then design

Renters found homes easily. Choosing between them was the hard part, so that's what I redesigned.

Rightmove is one of the UK's largest property platforms. I tested where it creates friction for renters making a high-stakes decision, then designed three changes around what I found.

The Rightmove app's home screen on a phone lying on an orange sofa, with dog toys beside it and a pug looking in from the corner.
Independent concept project. Not affiliated with or commissioned by Rightmove.

The Problem

In a big decision, small gaps became trust problems.

Search worked well. The friction came at the point of decision: unclear listings, hard-to-find filters and no way to compare properties.

Research Process

I watched people search, instead of asking them about it.

Five people who had used property sites before each looked for a one-bedroom rental in Edinburgh, compared their options and thought aloud as they went. I transcribed every session and grouped what kept coming up.

  • Participants 5

    All had used property platforms before.

  • Core task 1

    Everyone did the same task, so I could compare sessions.

  • Usability testing Think-aloud

    To see what people do, not what they say they do.

  • Synthesis Affinity mapping

    To pull out what kept coming up.

What I Found

What's already working

Participants navigated Rightmove easily and completed the core search task without difficulty. The problem wasn't finding properties. It was evaluating them.

01

Important information was unclear or missing

Floor plans, floor level, property type and pet policies weren't consistently clear, making some listings harder to trust.

Doodle of a floor plan.

"No floor plan… I don't trust that."

Doodle of a bulldog sitting with its head tilted and a question mark above it.

"Pets considered… I don't really know what that means."

02

Finding basic controls took too long

Participants often had to dig through listings or leave Rightmove entirely to find information they expected to see immediately.

This became particularly clear when trying to exclude flat shares: the option existed, but was buried at the bottom of a collapsed filter panel.

Usability test: a participant trying to hide flat shares in the filters.

03

Comparing properties relied on memory

Participants saved multiple properties, but had no way to compare them directly.

On mobile, that meant repeatedly switching between listings and remembering the differences rather than seeing them side by side.

Doodle of two houses side by side with an arrow between them.

"I don't know if there's a way to compare them directly… that would be very cool."

Designing the Fix

Three findings. Three targeted changes.

Before and after · 1 of 2

01

Make listing details explicit

Before

Floor plans, floor level and pet policy were missing or vague, which made listings harder to trust.

A Rightmove listing on a phone. After the photo and price come letting details, where council tax reads Ask agent, then property type, the floor plan and the description. Council tax band, parking, garden and accessibility only appear below the description. Floor level and pets are not shown.

After

I made a floor plan the default and pulled floor level and pet policy into a clear info grid, replacing vague labels.

The reworked listing. Under the price is an Add to compare button, then property type, bedrooms and size, the floor plan and photos, and one grid for council tax, parking, garden, accessibility, floor level and pets, where pets reads Not provided. Letting details and the description follow.

02

Surface the filters people actually need

Before

The option to exclude flat shares sat in the last section of the filter panel, collapsed by default.

  • Flat shares can only be excluded under "Don't show", at the very bottom.
Rightmove's filter panel on a phone: property type, area, price, bedrooms, bathrooms, furnished type, type of let, property details, must haves, and Don't show as the last section, collapsed.

After

I moved "Don't show" up from the bottom of the panel to sit straight after the basics, so hiding flat shares no longer means scrolling past everything else.

  • "Don't show" is now sixth, right after the filters people set first.
  • Less-used filters move to the end.
The reordered filter panel: price, bedrooms, bathrooms, property type, furnished type, then Don't show, followed by must haves, area, type of let and property details.

03

Let people compare, not remember

I designed a mobile-first comparison tool for saved properties, highlighting the fields that differ so users can evaluate options side by side instead of switching back and forth.

In action
A Compare screen asking you to select 2 properties to compare side by side. Two saved properties are ticked, Downfield Place at £1,050 pcm and Smithfield Street at £950 pcm, above a Compare selected (2) button.
Choosing what to compare
The two properties side by side with a Show differences only switch. Rows for monthly rent, deposit, available from, bedrooms, furnished, floor level, pets, parking, garden and council tax; rows that differ are tinted green and missing details read Not provided. Two Contact agent buttons sit at the bottom.
Side by side

Success Metrics

How I'd know the changes worked.

These are what I'd measure, not results. Each change has one measure, tied to the problem it was meant to fix.

  • 01 · Listing details Time to find key details

    If floor level and pet policy take seconds to find, the info grid is working.

  • 02 · Filters First-attempt success

    If people can exclude flat shares without hunting, the filter is in the right place.

  • 03 · Comparison Comparison adoption

    If people with saved properties compare them side by side, it's replacing memory.

The business measure behind all three is enquiries sent to agents. Clearer listings might mean fewer enquiries but more serious ones, so I wouldn't judge it on numbers alone. I'd ask agents whether the enquiries they got were better.

Reflection

What I took from it.

Products that work can still fall short. Everyone completed the search, but the gaps were in the details: content, structure and features people expected. It taught me to look closely, even at products that seem fine.

Not every UX problem is an interface problem. Some details may be missing because agents don't supply them. Agents are also Rightmove's paying customers, so a real fix would balance their needs with renters'.

Next, I'd test the redesigns. I'd start with the filter change, the smallest to build and easiest to measure, and speak to agents about what they can and can't include on a listing.

Thanks for reading

Hanna